Published on LinkedIn September 7, 2026
Prosci, Kotter, and Lean are treated as rival schools of thought in change management circles, each with its own certification and loyalists. That instinct is backwards. Each framework was built to answer a different question, at a different level of the organization, and neuroscience explains why each one works.
The debate over which one is “right” wastes energy that should go toward diagnosing the actual problem in front of you. A framework isn’t a philosophy to adopt. It’s a tool built to solve a specific human problem, and most transformations run into more than one of those problems at once.
This is part one of a two-part series on choosing and combining change frameworks. Part two looks at using all three as a diagnostic toolkit instead of picking a favourite.
What each framework actually answers
Prosci’s ADKAR model operates at the individual level. It asks what one person needs to move through change: Awareness of why the change is happening, Desire to support it, Knowledge of how to do it, Ability to actually do it, and Reinforcement to keep them from sliding back. Prosci built the model after studying change patterns across more than 700 organizations. It answers a narrow question: what does this specific person need right now? ADKAR doesn’t care about the org chart or the business case. It cares whether one human being has enough reason, information, and skill to change their own behaviour, and whether that change will stick once the project team moves on.
Kotter’s 8-Step Process operates at the organizational level. It asks how an entire enterprise moves together. The steps run in sequence: build urgency, form a coalition, set a vision, communicate it, remove barriers, generate short-term wins, and lock the change into how the organization actually operates. Kotter developed the model after studying more than 100 companies attempting major transformation. It answers a different question: how do we get a whole system moving in the same direction? ADKAR can get an individual ready to change. It can’t build the urgency or the coalition needed to get a thousand individuals ready at the same time. That’s a separate problem, and it’s the one Kotter’s model was built to solve.
Lean Change Management operates at the level of uncertainty. Jason Little built it by blending Agile, Lean Startup, and organizational psychology, with roots tracing back to the Toyota Production System’s discipline of small, continuous improvements rather than one big redesign. Instead of a fixed sequence, it runs on a loop: gather insights, generate options, run a small experiment, then decide whether to pursue, pivot, or pause. Little frames the model around five reframes he calls the Universals of Change, including co-creation rather than selling people on a decision, real dialogue rather than scripted town halls, and treating resistance as data rather than a problem to overcome. It answers a third question: what do we do when we don’t yet know the destination? Kotter assumes leadership already knows where it’s going and needs to rally people toward it. Lean assumes the destination itself might shift as the organization learns and builds its methodology around that assumption rather than resisting it.
These three questions don’t compete. A single transformation usually needs all three answered, for different people, at different points in the work.
Why the brain needs all three
Kotter’s own research team describes what they call the Survive and Thrive system. Humans evolved with a built-in survival channel that scans for threats before it scans for opportunity. Most leaders underestimate how strongly that instinct overrides a team’s ability to see opportunity or adapt. That’s exactly why urgency and coalition-building come first in Kotter’s model. Skip them, and the survival channel wins by default.
The NeuroLeadership Institute’s SCARF model explains a related problem from another angle. Status, Certainty, Autonomy, Relatedness, and Fairness trigger the same threat or reward response in the brain as physical safety and food. Threaten any of these five, and the brain struggles to focus, decide, or collaborate well.
The Institute’s newest research is worth sitting with. It’s based on more than 15,000 assessments collected in 2024 and 2025. In 2012, Certainty and Relatedness were the strongest drivers of engagement at work. By 2025, Fairness and Autonomy had taken the top spots, and Certainty had fallen to the bottom. People no longer need to be told exactly what’s coming next. They need to trust the process is fair, and they need some say in how they get there.
That shift explains why some frameworks land better than others right now. Prosci’s Reinforcement stage and Kotter’s short-term wins were built for a workforce that prized certainty above nearly everything else. Lean’s insistence on co-creation over broadcast communication, and options over mandates, is built for a workforce that now prizes autonomy and fairness more.
The research also found that sensitivity to these five domains isn’t uniform. It varies by role and by gender, with women reporting higher overall sensitivity across all five domains, and a particularly strong response to Status and Fairness. Senior leaders, meanwhile, tend to need less Certainty and more Autonomy than the people they manage, which is its own blind spot if you’re the one designing the change plan.
The practical takeaway
None of this makes Prosci or Kotter outdated. It means each framework was quietly built to satisfy a specific set of psychological needs, and those needs shift depending on the person, the organization, and the moment. Lean’s rise in popularity over the past decade isn’t a rejection of the older models. It’s a response to a workforce whose brains are now weighing fairness and autonomy more heavily than certainty, which is exactly what the newest SCARF data shows.
A change leader who understands ADKAR, the 8 Steps, and the Lean Change Engine isn’t just collecting credentials. They’re building a working map of which human need is unmet in front of them right now, and which framework was designed to meet it.
Part two of this series looks at how to use that map in practice. It covers diagnosing the organization, the people, and the project before choosing a methodology. It also covers why reducing, combining, or stripping down frameworks is often the more sophisticated move.
Sources:
- Prosci, “The Prosci ADKAR® Model”: https://www.prosci.com/methodology/adkar
- Prosci, “Aligning the ADKAR Model With Sequential, Iterative and Hybrid Change”: https://www.prosci.com/blog/aligning-the-adkar-model-with-sequential-iterative-and-hybrid-change
- Kotter Inc, “The 8-Step Process for Leading Change”: https://www.kotterinc.com/methodology/8-steps/
- Kotter Inc, “The Science of Change” (Survive + Thrive): https://www.kotterinc.com/methodology/the-science-of-change/
- Lean Change Management, official methodology overview: https://leanchange.org/
- NeuroLeadership Institute, “The Evolution of the Social Brain: Introducing SCARF in 2025”: https://www.neuroleadership.com/articles/the-evolution-of-the-social-brain-introducing-scarf-in-2025
Strategic Signals publishes monthly on strategy systems and execution clarity for senior leaders. Subscribe to receive each issue directly. Subscribe
If this piece resonated, ALIGN: The Leadership Framework for Clarity in Complex Organizations is available on Amazon. Click Here
